• 13 Posts
  • 4.87K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 15th, 2023

help-circle
















  • FuglyDuck@lemmy.worldtoScience Memes@mander.xyzMythbusters
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    18 hours ago

    Just to clarify; you understand that because the engines are pushing on the plane itself and not the wheels, by the time the wheels start moving, the plane is already moving relative to ground and air alike.

    Which, said another way, this thought problem appears confusing because it’s being considered from otherwise irrelevant reference frames.

    An anchor sufficient to keep the plane from rolling forward is different because the force it is apply is significantly greater.

    Sure, you can deflate the tires and increase the rate of spin on the wheels. But at that point, you might as well ask “can we creat a scenario where planes can’t take off”

    To which the answer is definitely “Yes”,

    And as a side note, if we assume the wheels are indestructible, which I’d argue is only fair, then even if what you’re saying is true and we ramp up the drag induced by the wheels sufficient to counter the engines… then the wind generated by the rolling treadmill would be producing a sufficient headwind for the plane to take off. (Remember, the air resistance of the treadmill’s belt moving will accelerate the air some.)

    But again, the wheels have almost zero drag to begin with, the speed at which the roll is independent of both the actual groundspeed and the airspeed of the airplane.

    If it has the thrust to over come friction at take off speeds, and at standing, then it has enough power to get to take off velocity eventually.

    On the other hand, this entire conversation assumes the thrust to weight ratio is less than 1. If it’s more than one, well they just…. Go straight up.




  • FuglyDuck@lemmy.worldtoScience Memes@mander.xyzMythbusters
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    21 hours ago

    Except it’s not like attaching an anchor. The plane isn’t physically attached.

    The wheels will just roll double whatever the current ground speed is. If the plane has enough thrust to take off with the treadmill moving an inverse of its take off speed, then it has enough force to start rolling, too.

    At most, the force applied by the treadmill would be sufficient over enough time to lengthen the take off roll, but given enough space to do so, the plane will take off.

    To keep the plane from rolling forward; the treadmill would have to be able to apply an equal force as the engines, it can’t do that through the wheels- the wheels can only apply a force equal to their rolling resistance and friction in its mechanics.