I would describe it as Napoleon Dynamite meets Mister Rogers directed by Wes Anderson.
It’s a lovely show that got cancelled after 3 seasons, but the seasons they got were really special and worth watching. There’s a very subtle, sweet storyline throughout the story that isn’t immediately obvious if you just jump around via clips.
It started creeping me out the more I thought about it being a character tbh. I know he’s probably playing up his real personality, I think it gets creepy when people are obviously genuinely reacting to his persona thinking it’s real. Just something uncanny about it that creeps me out.
Yet I love Nathan Fielder so I dunno.
I felt the same way, believe it or not. Having seen him recently on the Townsends channel, for example, it felt pretty natural: https://youtu.be/Eawb8V6f1IU?si=hzX_yregm_0wZgda