Condemning either group for the actions of a few

Is not what Kate Lister or feminist in general are doing. They’re saying that they are afraid of being alone with a man, this is just how they feel.

they observe a few correlations from time to time

Here in France, 96% of sexual assaults are performed by men. I don’t think you could find a country where the statistic goes the other way. “a few correlations from time to time” really doesn’t reflect the reality of the situation. It’s not some correlation, it’s a systemic issue in our society.

Before long, critical thinking goes out the window, correlation is assumed to be causation and you’ve got men reacting aggressively to posts that say they are dangerous and women saying “I chose the bear!” even though they know that is staticallyess safe because it aligns with the message they think they need to share because they buy into the same stereotype the men did and vice versa.

I actually agree that critical thinking goes out the window ! “I chose the bear!” is meant to express that women are afraid of men. The fact that most women would actually be terrified of an encounter with a bear or that they are statistically safer with a man than with a bear is irrelevant. Women want to send a message and instead of listening, you are correcting them on a technicality.

Talking about the issue is fine but this discourse is flawed.

The fact that you are only talking about the discourse and not the actual problem makes me wonder if you really want the issue to be resolved

Imagine how it would play out if the question was “white people, would you rather be stranded on a island with a black person or an alligator?”

This is a terrible comparison. When woman say they are afraid of men, it’s a dominated group being afraid of its dominators. With your black perso/alligator question, it’s a case of dominators being afraid of a group its dominating.

Buying the house would be a lot cheaper if landlord weren’t hoarding properties, then you might have a 1300 a month mortgage instead of a 1300 a month rent

Je trouve que c’est dommage de se vexer pour si peu, enfin perso je tombe pas sur ce genre de réactions si souvent que ça. D’autant que de notre côté on est pas les derniers à faire le même genre de blague sur les anglais ou les américains.

remplacez “French people” et “French language” par Arab, Chinese ou African

On est quand même pas sur le même niveau de discrimination et de haine, donc forcément une blague de mauvais goût sur la France et les français ne va pas provoquer la même réaction qu’une blague sur les noirs ou les arabes